Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Oz's avatar

"Australia is the last, strangest child of the New World. It is bound by no inherited style."

Probably that is technically New Zealand...

Kris's avatar

Thanks for this. It’s an invigorating piece, and I recognise the frustration behind it. Anyone who’s spent time around panels, prizes, grants, and the polite moral choreography of Australian letters knows exactly what you’re pushing against.

Where I want to gently resist is the idea that realism, or political seriousness, is the primary culprit. Some of the most destabilising work we have is realist on the surface. Tsiolkas, Garner, Scott, Temple, Lohrey. None of them are safe, "consensus" writers, even when they’re legible. Their danger isn’t ontological fireworks but proximity. Bodies, class, sex, violence, institutions, shame. The unsettling comes from staying with the material rather than transcending it.

I also think the postcolonial critique gets flattened a bit here. Kim Scott isn’t writing box-ticking history. He’s doing language work, archive work, metaphysical work. The politics are not an external obligation but the condition of the writing. When that becomes dreary, it’s usually because institutions have turned ethics into admin, not because writers are incapable of play or strangeness.

What I do agree with completely is your diagnosis of institutional legibility as the real sickness. The pressure to be explicable, correct, fundable, blurbed. That’s where ambition gets shaved down. That’s where seriousness turns into piety. And that pressure hits working-class writers hardest, because the room was never built for us to begin with.

So, my question is this. Is the enemy really realism and history, or is it the demand that art arrive pre-interpreted and morally hygienic? And if Australian writing has failed to fully metabolise the weirdness of this place, is that because writers lack imagination, or because the machinery only rewards what can be safely recognised?

Either way, I’m glad you wrote it. Pieces like this make it easier for people like me to believe that writing a book isn’t an act of bad manners.

21 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?